Consignment to Coin Dealers

PNNA Home / Reference / Buy-Sell / Consignment

Coin Buying and Selling - Consignment to Coin Dealers

You should carefully consider the available options and their advantages and disadvantages before proceeding.

This method of selling coins, in which the collector chooses a coin dealer to sell his/her coins, but does not receive payment until the coins are actually sold, has become more popular in recent years.

Advantages

bullet

As in major auctions, dealers may be willing to accept a smaller commission (perhaps 20%) if they don't have to use their own cash to purchase inventory, which can sometimes remain unsold for months or even years.

bullet

As with direct sale, this method may be more private and secure than advertising your coins to the public.

Disadvantages

bullet

You don't get paid for your coins right away, and some items may remain unsold.

bullet

Obvious risk of theft while coins are in dealer's possession, and risk that a dishonest dealer might disappear with your coins.

bullet

Price uncertainty due to market fluctuations and other factors before your coins are actually sold.

Advice

bullet

This method of sale should only be used with established, reputable dealers, preferable those you have done business with before.

bullet

Always get a receipt for your coins, agree on a minimum selling price and commission, and ask what happens in the event of loss. Also agree on a time limit after which unsold items should be returned to you.